| Coldwater Baseball Records | ||||
| All-Time versus Opponents | ||||
| All-Time | 1st Year | Last Year | ||
| Opponent | Record | Played | Played | Streak |
| Adams Central | 4-1 | 1982 lost 5-6 | 1987 won 9-4 | Won 4 |
| Allen East | 5-0 | 1966 won 3-1 | 2002 won 10-0 | Won 5 |
| Akron St. Vincent | 1-0 | 1992 won 8-0 | 1992 won 8-0 | Won 1 |
| Anna | 1-0 | 1995 won 10-2 | 1995 won 10-2 | Won 1 |
| Ansonia | 10-0 | 1956 won 22-5 | 1978 won 26-2 | Won 10 |
| Antwerp | 1-0 | 1989 won 15-0 | 1989 won 15-0 | Won 1 |
| Arcanum | 4-1 | 1993 lost 3-4 | 1998 won 7-2 | Won 4 |
| Archbold | 1-0 | 1983 won 6-0 | 1983 won 6-0 | Won 1 |
| Ayersville | 2-1 | 1961 won 3-1 | 2007 lost 4-7 | Lost 1 |
| Bath (Lima) | 33-18 | 1971 won 6-5 | 2008 won 8-4 | Won 1 |
| Bellefontaine | 8-1 | 1958 won 4-3 | 1992 won 18-2 | Won 6 |
| Belleview | 0-1 | 1985 lost 3-4 | 1985 lost 3-4 | Lost 1 |
| Ben Logan | 1-0 | 1990 won 6-0 | 1990 won 6-0 | Won 1 |
| Bettsville | 1-0 | 1961 won 5-1 | 1961 won 5-1 | Won 1 |
| Bowling Green | 4-0 | 2001 won 7-5 | 2002 won 10-7 | Won 4 |
| Bradford | 5-0 | 1974 won 14-2 | 1978 won 9-0 | Won 5 |
| Bronson, Michigan | 1-0 | 1977 won 5-2 | 1977 won 5-2 | Won 1 |
| Bryan | 9-0 | 1977 won 3-2 | 1993 won 6-4 | Won 9 |
| Buckland | 2-0 | 1961 won 6-4 | 1962 won 4-1 | Won 2 |
| Bucyrus (Wynford) | 5-0 | 1987 won 7-5 | 2004 won 10-0 | Won 5 |
| Canton Central Catholic | 0-1 | 2008 lost 4-5 | 2008 lost 4-5 | Lost 1 |
| Celina | 68-17 | 1950 won 10-2 | 2008 won 6-3 | Won 2 |
| Celina I.C. | 10-1 | 1950 won 21-8 | 1965 won 9-6 | Won 6 |
| Cincinnati Deerpark | 0-1 | 1977 lost 0-6 | 1977 lost 0-6 | Lost 1 |
| Cincinnati Indian Hills | 0-1 | 1993 lost 4-5 | 1993 lost 4-5 | Lost 1 |
| Cincinnati Mason | 1-0 | 1987 won 22-5 | 1987 won 22-5 | Won 1 |
| Clearfork (Amanda) | 1-0 | 2000 won 6-2 | 2000 won 6-2 | Won 1 |
| Columbus Desales | 1-0 | 1983 won 4-0 | 1983 won 4-0 | Won 1 |
| Columbus Grove | 1-0 | 1984 won 14-2 | 1984 won 14-2 | Won 1 |
| Columbus Hartley | 1-0 | 1991 won 11-5 | 1991 won 11-5 | Won 1 |
| Convoy | 1-0 | 1953 won 6-0 | 1953 won 6-0 | Won 1 |
| Covington | 1-0 | 1973 won 17-12 | 1973 won 17-12 | Won 1 |
| Crestview | 13-0 | 1961 won 6-2 | 2005 won 10-0 | Won 13 |
| Dayton Stebbins | 2-0 | 1975 won 6-0 | 1975 won 6-0 | Won 2 |
| Dayton Wayne | 6-3 | 1983 lost 1-3 | 1990 won 7-6 | Won 1 |
| Decator | 1-1 | 1975 lost 5-10 | 1975 won 5-3 | Won 1 |
| Defiance | 1-0 | 1995 won 12-6 | 1995 won 12-6 | Won 1 |
| Dekalb | 0-2 | 1977 lost 2-5 | 1979 lost 1-2 | Lost 2 |
| Delphos Jefferson | 5-3 | 2000 won 8-1 | 1953 won 5-0 | Won 3 |
| Delphos St. Johns | 34-7 | 1961 won 16-4 | 2008 won 10-0 | Won 7 |
| Dixie | 0-1 | 1964 lost 0-1 | 1964 lost 0-1 | Lost 1 |
| Eaton | 1-0 | 2005 won 13-5 | 2005 won 13-5 | Won 1 |
| Elida | 38-11 | 1954 won 4-2 | 2008 won 10-0 | Won 8 |
| Elkhart Central | 1-0 | 1979 won 7-6 | 1979 won 7-6 | Won 1 |
| Elmwood (Bloomdale) | 4-0 | 2000 won 2-0 | 1991 won 2-0 | Won 4 |
| Elyria West | 0-1 | 1986 lost 3-4 | 1986 lost 3-4 | Lost 1 |
| Evergreen (Fairview) | 4-1 | 1973 won 10-2 | 1979 won 5-4 | Won 2 |
| Fairborn | 1-1 | 1994 won 14-9 | 1994 lost 7-9 | Lost 1 |
| Findlay | 3-1 | 2007 won 7-1 | 2008 won 9-5 | Won 1 |
| Franklin Monroe | 1-1 | 1978 lost 4-6 | 1989 won 11-4 | Won 1 |
| Ft. Jennings | 3-0 | 2000 won 14-2 | 2005 won 10-0 | Won 3 |
| Ft. Loramie | 19-7 | 1967 lost 4-7 | 2008 won 14-0 | Won 1 |
| Ft. Recovery | 51-3 | 1950 lost 2-9 | 2008 won 8-0 | Won 29 |
| Gahanna Academy (Col) | 1-0 | 2004 won 8-3 | 2004 won 8-3 | Won 1 |
| Garfield Heights | 1-0 | 1984 won 5-3 | 1984 won 5-3 | Won 1 |
| Genoa | 3-0 | 2000 won 13-5 | 1983 won 14-4 | Won 3 |
| Gomer | 0-1 | 1952 lost 2-3 | 1952 lost 2-3 | Lost 1 |
| Greenville | 18-2 | 1975 lost 2-4 | 2008 won 6-5 | Won 17 |
| Hamilton Badin | 1-1 | 1984 won 8-4 | 1991 lost 1-2 | Lost 1 |
| Hicksville | 2-0 | 1953 won 16-8 | 1954 won 4-1 | Won 2 |
| Hillsdale (Jeromesville) | 1-0 | 1995 won 14-0 | 1995 won 14-0 | Won 1 |
| Houston | 5-0 | 1973 won 8-2 | 2002 won 13-6 | Won 5 |
| Indian Lake | 7-1 | 1976 won 7-6 | 1991 won 13-1 | Won 6 |
| Jay County | 0-2 | 1981 lost 1-7 | 1981 lost 1-7 | Lost 2 |
| Kalida | 1-0 | 1965 won 5-1 | 1965 won 5-1 | Won 1 |
| Kansas Lakota | 1-1 | 1992 won 2-0 | 1994 lost 7-10 | Lost 1 |
| Kenton | 6-2 | 1958 won 7-5 | 1997 lost 7-8 | Lost 1 |
| L.C.C. | 31-10 | 1959 lost 5-7 | 2008 won 8-1 | Won 2 |
| Liberty Union | 0-1 | 1961 lost 2-7 | 1961 lost 2-7 | Lost 1 |
| Lima Senior | 11-3 | 1960 lost 4-9 | 2006 won 13-1 | Won 5 |
| Lincoln Heights | 0-1 | 1970 lost 1-2 | 1970 lost 1-2 | Lost 1 |
| Lincolnview | 5-1 | 1962 lost 3-9 | 1990 won 9-2 | Won 5 |
| Loraine Catholic | 1-0 | 1990 won 13-10 | 1990 won 13-10 | Won 1 |
| Mansfield Malibar | 1-0 | 1986 won 7-2 | 1986 won 7-2 | Won 1 |
| Marbury Lake | 0-1 | 1978 lost 2-6 | 1978 lost 2-6 | Lost 1 |
| Marimount | 0-1 | 1995 lost 0-3 | 1995 lost 0-3 | Lost 1 |
| Marion Local | 57-5 | 1960 won 10-2 | 2008 won 10-2 | Won 5 |
| Marion Pleasant | 1-0 | 2008 won 4-0 | 2008 won 4-0 | Won 1 |
| McGuffey | 1-0 | 1964 won 1-0 | 1964 won 1-0 | Won 1 |
| Mendon-Union | 20-0 | 1951 won 14-3 | 1992 won 18-0 | Won 20 |
| Middletown | 1-1 | 1991 lost 5-7 | 1991 won 5-2 | Won 1 |
| Millbury Lake | 5-0 | 1987 won 15-5 | 1991 won 8-2 | Won 5 |
| Miller City | 1-0 | 1989 won 7-1 | 1989 won 7-1 | Won 1 |
| Minster | 43-9 | 1962 won 10-6 | 2008 won 8-1 | Won 1 |
| Mississinawa Valley | 4-0 | 1978 won 17-1 | 2007 won 19-1 | Won 4 |
| Napoleon | 2-0 | 1972 won 4-0 | 1985 won 4-3 | Won 2 |
| National Trail | 1-0 | 1991 won 7-1 | 1991 won 7-1 | Won 1 |
| New Albany | 0-1 | 2004 lost 4-5 | 2004 lost 4-5 | Lost 1 |
| New Bremen | 54-3 | 1954 won 5-4 | 2008 won 10-4 | Won 2 |
| New Knoxville | 40-2 | 1960 won 5-4 | 2008 won 16-0 | Won 35 |
| Newark Catholic | 1-1 | 1989 lost 1-7 | 1990 won 3-2 | Won 1 |
| Northwest McDormet | 1-0 | 1983 won 13-2 | 1983 won 13-2 | Won 1 |
| Northwood | 2-0 | 1990 won 12-1 | 1992 won 3-2 | Won 2 |
| Ohio City | 10-2 | 1967 won 6-0 | 1977 won 20-7 | Won 6 |
| Olmstead Falls | 1-0 | 1987 won 7-2 | 1987 won 7-2 | Won 1 |
| Oregon Cardinal Strich | 1-0 | 1984 won 12-0 | 1984 won 12-0 | Won 1 |
| Ottawa-Glandorf | 6-2 | 1980 won 9-1 | 2008 won 3-0 | Won 1 |
| Ottoville | 0-1 | 1982 lost 0-1 | 1982 lost 0-1 | Lost 1 |
| Parkway | 48-11 | 1964 won 3-2 | 2008 won 14-7 | Won 1 |
| Patrick Henry | 2-3 | 2002 lost 0-2 | 2007 won 3-0 | Won 1 |
| Paulding | 8-0 | 1955 won 6-2 | 2008 won 11-1 | Won 8 |
| Pemberville Eastwood | 3-0 | 1977 won 9-4 | 1996 won 7-2 | Won 3 |
| Perry (Cleveland) | 1-0 | 2004 won 5-4 | 2004 won 5-4 | Won 1 |
| Perry (Lima) | 1-1 | 1999 lost 1-5 | 2000 won 7-2 | Won 1 |
| Piqua | 6-1 | 1987 won 12-4 | 1993 won 11-5 | Won 2 |
| Piqua Catholic | 1-0 | 1964 won 6-1 | 1964 won 6-1 | Won 1 |
| Port Clinton | 1-0 | 1977 won 4-2 | 1977 won 4-2 | Won 1 |
| Portland | 2-2 | 1954 lost 0-7 | 1957 lost 2-6 | Lost 1 |
| Richmond Jefferson | 1-0 | 1977 won 5-4 | 1977 won 5-4 | Won 1 |
| Russia | 16-2 | 1970 lost 1-4 | 1996 won 9-2 | Won 14 |
| Sandusky Perkins | 1-0 | 1972 won 3-1 | 1972 won 3-1 | Won 1 |
| Shawnee (Lima) | 26-14 | 1958 lost 0-1 | 2008 lost 4-5 | Lost 1 |
| Sheridan | 1-0 | 1987 won 10-4 | 1987 won 10-4 | Won 1 |
| Sherwood (Fairview) | 10-1 | 1975 won 4-2 | 2008 won 2-1 | Won 8 |
| Sidney | 2-0 | 1977 won 6-5 | 1977 won 8-2 | Won 2 |
| Sidney Lehman | 2-0 | 1976 won 8-5 | 2008 won 10-0 | Won 1 |
| Solon (Cleveland) | 0-1 | 1972 lost 1-2 | 1972 lost 1-2 | Lost 1 |
| South Adams | 3-2 | 1971 lost 1-3 | 1984 won 20-10 | Won 2 |
| Spencerville | 13-1 | 1963 won 6-1 | 2005 won 10-0 | Won 12 |
| Springfield Kenton Ridge | 1-0 | 1992 won 17-4 | 1992 won 17-4 | Won 1 |
| St. Henry | 53-19 | 1950 won 11-10 | 2008 won 4-1 | Won 6 |
| St. Johns (Maria Stein) | 4-1 | 1950 won 4-1 | 1952 won 6-4 | Won 3 |
| St. Marys | 34-28 | 1956 lost 3-4 | 2008 won 7-3 | Won 2 |
| St. Rose (Lima) | 0-1 | 1954 lost 2-8 | 1954 lost 2-8 | Lost 1 |
| Strongsville | 0-1 | 2006 lost 8-14 | 2006 lost 8-14 | Lost 1 |
| Tipp City | 1-0 | 1972 won 4-2 | 1972 won 4-2 | Won 1 |
| Toledo Central Catholic | 0-1 | 1959 lost 0-4 | 1959 lost 0-4 | Lost 1 |
| Toledo Ottawa Hills | 0-1 | 1988 lost 5-8 | 1988 lost 5-8 | Lost 1 |
| Toledo Start | 0-2 | 1993 lost 1-3 | 1994 lost 0-8 | Lost 2 |
| Tontogany Otsego | 2-0 | 1993 won 11-2 | 1996 won 9-2 | Won 2 |
| Troy | 1-0 | 1995 won 10-0 | 1995 won 10-0 | Won 1 |
| Upper Scioto Valley | 1-0 | 1970 won 2-1 | 1970 won 2-1 | Won 1 |
| Urbana | 3-0 | 1983 won 12-2 | 1985 won 9-1 | Won 3 |
| Ursuline (Youngstown) | 0-1 | 2000 lost 3-4 | 2000 lost 3-4 | Lost 1 |
| Utica | 1-0 | 1992 won 6-5 | 1992 won 6-5 | Won 1 |
| Vandalia-Butler | 9-13 | 2000 lost 2-14 | 2008 won 3-2 | Won 1 |
| Van Wert | 57-22 | 1956 lost 0-3 | 2008 won 10-1 | Won 12 |
| Versailles | 19-5 | 1958 won 6-2 | 2008 won 6-0 | Won 2 |
| Wapakoneta | 35-10 | 1959 won 9-2 | 2007 won 4-2 | Won 3 |
| Wapak Blume | 2-0 | 1958 won 21-2 | 1961 won 5-4 | Won 2 |
| Wapak St. Joe | 8-1 | 1956 won 12-0 | 1973 won 4-3 | Won 6 |
| Wauseon | 1-0 | 1986 won 21-1 | 1986 won 21-1 | Won 1 |
| Waynesfield | 1-0 | 1962 won 16-2 | 1962 won 16-2 | Won 1 |
| Wayne Trace | 2-1 | 1984 won 6-0 | 2002 won 11-1 | Won 1 |
| Wheelersburg | 0-1 | 1996 lost 0-1 | 1996 lost 0-1 | Lost 1 |
| Wren | 1-0 | 1952 won 6-2 | 1952 won 6-2 | Won 1 |
| 1950-2008 | ||||